Windows Live Sync vs. Live Mesh vs. SkyDrive: Which is Right for You?

via Digital Inspiration – Technology Blog by Amit Agarwal on 12/20/08

The new Windows Live suite includes three different services for file storage and online synchronization. They are called Live Mesh, Windows Live Sync and Windows Live SkyDrive – all apps are available for free and you just need a Windows Live account to get started.

Windows Live SkyDrive

Windows Live SkyDrive is an online file storage service similar to Box.net. You can manually upload documents, pictures and other files to Windows Live servers via the browser and your uploads will remain accessible from any other computer or web-enabled mobile phone.

Windows Live SkyDrive requires no installation and you get 25 GB of free storage space though the maximum size of an individual file / document cannot exceed 50 MB. Each file or folder on SkyDrive has a unique Web address (URL), so you can easily paste that link into email messages or other documents for direct access.

Windows Live Sync

Windows Live Sync

Windows Live Sync, formerly known as FolderShare, is a desktop app + web service that lets you sync files and folders across different computers. You can synchronize up to 20 folders containing up to 20,000 files each. Individual files cannot be larger than 4 GB in size.

Say you have music files stored in your home computer’s hard disk and want to access this collection from the Office computer. Simply install Windows Live Sync of both the computers and add “my music” folder to your “personal folders” – now your entire music collection will be accessible from either of these computers.

Windows Live Sync also lets you remotely access your files on the hard drive from any other computer via the browser without setting up synchronization. This is handy in situations like where you have to download a presentation from your work computer that’s saved on the desktop – just browse to the desktop folder via Live Sync website and download the file.

Other than online synchronization, Windows Live Sync also lets invite family members and colleagues (as readers, contributors or owners) to access certain folders on your computer though they will have to install the Live Sync software for this.

Windows Live Mesh

Windows Live Mesh - Web View

Live Mesh includes everything that Windows Live Sync has to offer plus two extra features – cloud storage and remote desktop (with support for copy-paste).

You first need to download the Live Mesh software and then select folders / files that you want to sync with other computers. The process is almost the same as Live Sync but here you can add folders for synchronization from Windows Explorer itself (right click any folder and click “Add Folder to Live Mesh”) while Live Sync only offers a web interface to explorer.

When you add any folder to Live Mesh for synchronization, a copy of that folder gets stored online so you will always have access to your files even if the main computer is offline. This service is known as Live Desktop and offers 5 GB of online storage space.

Another important difference between Live Mesh and Windows Live Sync is Live Remote Desktop – Live Mesh lets you completely control the remote desktop just like other screen sharing application. You can even copy files and folders from the remote desktop to your local desktop through simple copy paste – copying folders manually is not possible in Windows Live Sync.

Both Live Mesh and Windows Live Sync offer clients for Windows and Mac but you may also install Live Mesh on mobile phones running Windows Mobile 6.1 or later.

Which Live Service is right for me? As expected, each of these Live services do have some overlapping features. Live Skydrive is for online storage, Live Sync is primarily for folder synchronization across computers (no storage) while Live Mesh offers a good mix of both though with limited storage space(5GB). Therefore my suggestion would be to go with SkyDrive as well as Live Mesh – you’ll get plenty of storage space plus remote desktop plus you can access important files from any other computer.

Windows Live Sync vs. Live Mesh vs. SkyDrive: Which is Right for You?

Digital Inspiration

One thought on “Windows Live Sync vs. Live Mesh vs. SkyDrive: Which is Right for You?

  1. I have recently tried the new Windows Live Sync. I use MS Onenote on my PC and my laptop and I love the “intelligent” sync feature, so I was looking for something similar in Live Sync. Onenote syncs all of my notebooks, and can distinguish the most recent changes I have made to any given folder instantaneously. Alas, to my chagrin, Windows Live Sync does not (yet?) have such a feature. I spent 30 mins sedulously deleting old files off of my PC, and when I went to sync the PC with the laptop, I found that my work was undone. Instead of updating my laptop (by deleting the aforementioned files from the laptop), Windows Live Sync “updated” my PC and put all of the old files back on the computer. I noticed another nasty little kink in the system when it came to the Music folder. Once again, instead of syncing, it simply transported a copy of the songs from my PC to my laptop, and vice versa – doubling the size of my Music folder on both computers!I subsequently removed all the folders from the Windows Live Sync site. They’re on the right track, but the program still seems a little rudimentary to me. If they decide to have “intelligent” syncing (like Onenote) then I’ll be the first to sign up. Anyone know if this feature is in Mesh?DA

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s